Email of the day (1)
"Enders Analysis has just published a report on paper. I am not a subscriber to Enders so only get the same summary you see here. It may nevertheless represent an interesting opportunity for the Collective. Maybe also there will be subscribers with direct experience of the paper industry which I do not. I would be interested in your thoughts."
Eoin Treacy's view Thank
you for this interesting question. Paper is a highly competitive business but
should benefit from the growth of the global middle class, led by the population
centres of Asia. Lumber and to a lesser extent cotton are important raw materials
for the sector.
Lumber
broke a five-year downtrend in November last year and had become relatively
overextended compared to the 200-day moving average by late April. It pulled
back into the previous range by early May and has now begun to lose downward
momentum in the region of the 200-day moving average. An upward dynamic is now
needed to check the decline while a sustained move back above $250 is required
to break the short-term progression of lower rally highs. (Also see Comment
of the Day on April
16th)
Cotton,
having doubled from the late 2008 low, has paused in the region of the 2008
and 2003 highs and is rapidly unwinding the overextension relative to the 200-day
MA. It is currently testing the lower side of the short-term range and an upward
dynamic, similar to those already posted within this range, is required to indicate
demand is returning at this level. A sustained move above 85¢ is needed
to reassert the medium-term uptrend.
This
is a list of some of the largest paper
related companies. Some are pure plays on paper and packaging while others also
have some exposure to transport and steel or plastic packaging so additional
research will be required as part of one's due diligence in vetting these companies.
One common aspect to this list is that countries with abundant timber resources
such as the USA, Brazil, Sweden and Finland are well represented. Interestingly,
no Canadian company makes it into the top-50 by market cap; perhaps because
they fall into forestry rather than paper companies. .
While
lumber prices have pulled back violently, timber related shares have been less
severely impacted and have generally held above their 200-day moving averages.
West Fraser Timber, which produces lumber
and paper remains in a consistent uptrend and is currently forming another equal-sized
consolidation. A sustained move below C$38.50 would be required to question
the consistency of the advance.
International
Paper rallied impressively from the March 2009 low but has now retraced
the entire panicky decline and lost momentum below $30. It found support above
$20 from early May but needs to sustain a move back above the 200-day moving
average near $23.50 to confirm demand is returning to dominance in the current
area.
Finland's
UPM-Kymmene found support above the previous
range from late April and is forming another relatively equal sized consolidation.
A sustained move below €9 would be required to question scope for further
upside.