China in Crisis? Another Credit Crunch in the West Is Far More Likely
Comment of the Day

February 01 2016

Commentary by David Fuller

China in Crisis? Another Credit Crunch in the West Is Far More Likely

Bad, yes. But getting worse? Recent movements in stock markets have been dominated by precipitous falls in China. China bears predict that the current issues will deepen, turning into troubles similar to those that caused the financial crisis of 2008-09. I do not think this will be the case.

In the past 20-odd years there have been three periods of bubble-like conditions globally: the technology boom of the late 1990s, the credit binge in the mid-2000s and a bubble in commodities in the last decade. The first boom led to overbuilding of cable infrastructure and permanent loss of capital in the technology sector.

The second boom led to over-borrowing and the default of several banks. The commodity bubble bursting is likely to lead to the default of commodity-producing businesses – and perhaps of some Chinese banks too – and to a glut of excess productive capacity.

If the primary result is cheap commodities, then many consumers and developing nations (such as India) will benefit.

Secondly, while the fragility of the financial system was exposed in 2008-09, I do not expect a rerun: especially in Britain and America, banks are much stronger and have learnt many lessons.

Crises rarely repeat themselves exactly, but investors naturally recall the last crisis and re-predict it, even if they almost certainly didn’t see it coming last time. There are too many vocal bears out there now compared with 2008. For example, RBS recently urged investors to “sell everything”. I cannot recall any such warning in 2007 or 2008.

• Time to 'sell everything'? No, this is when 'hold everything' works

My greater concern is that while looking for troubles in the East, investors are neglecting unsolved problems in the west. In the context of poor growth, the high levels of sovereign debt in many developed nations are unsustainable. This has been masked temporarily by the actions of central bankers, who have suppressed interest rates to historical lows and in turn made borrowing costs appear manageable.

David Fuller's view

This is a sensible article, in my opinion, and I think it will interest subscribers. 

 

Back to top

You need to be logged in to comment.

New members registration