Rising Chinese Inflation to Show Up in U.S. Imports
Comment of the Day

January 17 2011

Commentary by David Fuller

Rising Chinese Inflation to Show Up in U.S. Imports

This is an informative and topical article by Keith Bradsher for The New York Times. Here is the opening:
BEIJING - When garment buyers from New York show up next month at China's annual trade shows to bargain over next autumn's fashions, many will face sticker shock.

"They're going to go home with 35 percent less product than for the same dollars as last year," particularly for fur coats and cotton sportswear, said Bennett Model, chief executive of Cassin, a Manhattan-based line of designer clothing. "The consumer will definitely see the price rise."

Inflation has arrived in China. And after Tuesday's release of crucial financial statistics by China's central bank, few economists expect Beijing officials to be able to tame rising prices any time soon.

While American importers of Chinese goods will feel the squeeze, the effect on American consumers may be more subtle and the overall impact on United States inflation may be minimal.

There are simply too many other markups along the way - from transportation to salesclerks' wages - that affect the American retail prices of Chinese-made products. Excluding those markups, imports from China are equal to little more than 2 percent of the overall American economy.

The bigger consumer impact is in China itself. As China's booming economy enables more of its own citizens to buy the goods pouring out of its factories, Chinese consumers are feeling inflation directly. And Beijing is increasingly worried about the social unrest that could result.

In China, consumer prices were 5.1 percent higher in November than a year earlier, according to official government data. And many economists say the official figures actually understate the rate of inflation, which might in reality be twice as high.

"Four percent, China can bear it - beyond 5 percent, people will complain a lot," said Huo Jianguo, president of the Chinese
Academy of International Trade and Economic Cooperation here.

Higher global commodity prices, as well as rising wages in China, play roles in the increasing cost of Chinese goods. But economists say the main reason for the inflation now is China's foreign exchange reserves, which surged by a record amount in the fourth quarter.




The central bank has been pumping out currency at an ever-accelerating pace over the past decade to limit the renminbi's appreciation against the dollar. That strategy has helped preserve a competitive advantage of Chinese exporters by keeping their prices relatively low on global markets - while also protecting the jobs of tens of millions of Chinese workers in export factories.

David Fuller's view A number of central banks were printing money in excess of GDP growth before the 2008 meltdown - to keep their currencies competitive - and we know that quantitative easing followed that traumatic event. This led to record levels of paper money sloshing around the system, which the CBs hoped would reduce the risk of deflation by jumpstarting GDP growth once again.

This policy was largely successful - arguably too successful for Asian-led stronger economies which experienced no worse than growth recessions and are now fighting inflation, mainly from surging commodity prices which were no suprise for subscribers. (See also last Thursday's Comment of the Day.)

When commodity price inflation becomes an official concern, as it clearly has in many countries, it is also a headwind for equities to the extent that it poses a threat to GDP growth and corporate profitability. This headwind intensifies as interest rates increase.

Subscribers can expect some turbulence in stock markets while inflation remains near the front pages of newspaper business sections. However, commodity price inflation is a bigger threat to bond markets, especially where investors drove yields to record lows due to deflationary concerns.

Equities, rather than bonds, are a hedge against inflation provided interest rates do not rise sufficiently to risk recession. That risk does not appear high because there is little evidence of wage inflation, or scope for it, in the West. However there are pockets of wage inflation in the stronger economies.

I think that this disparity in inflationary pressures between the stronger and slower growth economies is largely responsible for changes in relative strength among stock markets over the last two to three months. For instance, the S&P 500 became a relative strength leader while inflationary concerns have weighed on India, as you can see from this weekly 5-year overlay chart.

This change in relative performance may persist for a while longer, until inflationary pressures have been fully discounted, but I do not think that it is a long-term factor. When relative performance next swings back in favour of India over Wall Street, that is likely to be an important signal.

Back to top