Stuff Happens, but Price still Matters
Policy mistakes have caused us to reassess 2012 earnings, economic growth, and asset price ranges. Short-term risks have risen, so have longer-term return prospects, in our view.
Our Mid Year Outlook of just a month ago was based on the economic framework of "muddle through" and gave policymakers some credit for, at the very least, not making major mistakes. We therefore expected stock markets to hold their March lows, but they have not. In our view, the reason for the breakdown in stocks and the spike in bond prices is that US and European policymakers have recently made significant blunders and, as a result, have lost credibility with investors, consumers, and business leaders.
"Dogmatic ECB policy and the political paralysis among European governments are the biggest threats to the global financial system" writes BCA this week, and we agree. We think US politicians have added to the problems by taking entrenched positions, thus signaling to investors that they are unlikely to address US fiscal problems until after the 2012 elections. With the elections set to be a referendum on two very different views of fiscal policy, business decision makers will be making hiring and investment decisions without clear policy direction, likely making them more cautious.
David Fuller's view Governments may not have distinguished themselves
in their handling of various crises large and small, but they seldom do, in
my opinion. In the west, I look to governments to promote a healthy democracy
in which we the people can feel sufficiently safe so that we can get on with
our lives, pursuing our ambitions within both the letter and spirit of just
laws.
I realised
and accepted long ago that governments would not preserve the purchasing power
of our fiat currencies. I live in hope, sometimes naively, that they will use
the powers to tax and regulate wisely, favouring an enterprise society based
on communitarian values, individual responsibility and equality of opportunity.
As an
investor, I hope for and seek evidence of good corporate governance, which is
often reflected in the share price and relative valuations provided by markets.
Among leading multinational companies which Fullermoney often favours, I think
standards of governance have improved considerably in recent years, and not
least because of the financial crisis in which the west is still mired.
In
many respects, the balance sheets of successful companies today are the antithesis
of their home country governments in the west. Prospering multinational firms
have reduced debt and waste, while increasing productivity and cash reserves.
I have described them as autonomies and investors need not despair in their
corporate world.
At Fullermoney,
we maintain that the main cause of this year's downturn in stock markets was
the spike in commodity prices, not least
with crude oil for which Brent is the
most relevant benchmark. Debt problems among governments, banks and consumers
certainly have not helped, but they are a known known, as Donald Rumsfeld said
in another context.
In this
year's earlier and ranging corrective phase for stock markets, during a standoff
between accommodative monetary policies and commodity price inflation, the latter
was always likely to win (see 5th
July's summary and earlier comments on this subject). I do not underestimate
the west's enormous debt problems, but they did not cause the world's growth
economies to tighten monetary policies.
Commodity
prices are still too high in our opinion. Against this background, Brazil, China,
India and the other growth economies will be reluctant to reverse their monetary
tightening bias, although there is cause for them to declare a neutral stance
before long, given that GDP growth is weakening.
I maintain
that the US economy needs Asian-led GDP growth to avoid a slide into recession.
Europe's economies are even weaker, and Germany's recent slowdown is a further
blow to confidence.
Until
we see some stimulus measures from growth economies, the Fed and the ECB - which
may or may not be imminent - this is not a comfortable environment for equities,
even though we see improving value in Eoin's share reviews. This month's earlier
downdraught, exacerbated by high-frequency trading, has obviously not helped
investor confidence, and more importantly, corporate sentiment.
Today's
Wall Street-led rally reflects investor hopes (or concerns among short sellers)
that Mr Bernanke will announce a new stimulus package at Jackson Hole this weekend.
That would be controversial but if he did, it would make more sense for him
to target the stock market if he wishes to boost confidence. Lower Treasury
bond yields would only increase concerns that the US was following Japan's deflationary
path.
Meanwhile,
charts for many stock market indices show a low on 8th or 9th August, followed
by churning, a brief rally, and a retest of the lower region. The big question:
Are these patterns the first distribution beneath top formations or a support
building process similar to this time last year?
Fullermoney
was more optimistic a year ago, but the charts will show us. For the bullish
case, we need to see sustained rallies above last week's highs for share indices
which show quite similar short-term patterns as you can see from these daily
charts for UKX, DAX,
SMI, SPX,
NDX, SPTSX,
IBOV, SHASHR,
HSI and AS51.
Some form of monetary stimulus would help investor confidence. Conversely, absence
of a stimulus and new closing lows for more than a day or two would reaffirm
the bear trends. A significant rally in Treasury
bond yields, which seems overdue, would help to mitigate recession and deflation
concerns.
The sell-off
has resulted in improved valuations, particularly regarding yields. We maintain
that earnings estimates, on average, are too high. Tactically, Fullermoney always
favours buying on weakness and selling on overextended rallies relative to trend
means approximated by 200-day MAs. Until stock market lows are confirmed, we
would not pay up for anything.