Turning gold into dross
WHILE equity and bond markets have remained relatively sanguine regarding the impasse in negotiations on America's debt ceiling, gold nevertheless achieved another (nominal) high today, at $1,622. That's one more milestone in an extraordinary run that began over a decade ago. As of Monday, gold's 10-year annualised real return was 16.8%. By comparison, American stocks managed a return of just 14.8% during the 1990s, in a roaring bull market.
Those kind of numbers are naturally prompting some debate concerning whether or not gold is in a bubble. While identifying bubbles is often challenging, gold is particularly tricky as it produces no cashflows and therefore has no intrinsic value.
What gold lacks in fundamental metrics, however, it makes up for with a lengthy record of historical prices, which are helpful in attacking the bubble question. For example, bullion dealer Kitco provides annual prices beginning in 1833. Adjusting the series for inflation, you come up with a long-term average price for gold of $483 per ounce-less than a third of its current price.
David Fuller's view As someone who
has long viewed gold as a monetary asset, as have countless numbers of people
over at least 6,000 years, I never cease to be surprised by the circumambulating
lengths some people go to in an effort to contrive an academic valuation for
gold in the post Bretton Woods era.
Trust
is far more important than any fundamental metric, for evaluating gold (historic,
monthly, weekly
& daily) and people have learned
or relearned that they cannot trust fiat currencies as a long-term store of
value. However, they will trust some of them more than others, with perceptions
regarding supply (money printing) being the key variable.
Gold
shows bubbly signs from time to time, in my view, based on the number of articles
and emails that I see, in addition to periodic spikes in the price. However,
having lived through the 1979 bubble in gold, I can say without hesitation that
we have seen nothing like that to date.
This
begs the question: will we see a similar bubble in the current secular trend?
My answer
is that we will see a bigger bubble this time, for several reasons: 1) much
more paper currency is being printed; 2) this time the debt situation is considerably
more ominous for western countries; 3) real interest rates are likely to remain
lower in these countries for longer; 4) and possibly most important of all,
many more middleclass and wealthy people around the world, who are interested
in gold, are also able to participate. They are also experiencing more inflation
in their faster growing economies.
Fullermoney
has long maintained that this secular bull market will end in a big bubble as
do most secular trends, from gold in the late 1970s to Japanese equities in
the late 1980s to tech in the late 1990s and house prices in many countries
in the last decade. We can also mention credit bubbles in the same breath.
When
gold is in an end-of-cycle climactic bubble phase, I think many more people
will actually own it rather than just talk about it. I would expect to see price
gains of $50 plus to $100 a day. Gold would also be entrenched as a front-page
news story.
I maintain
that gold's eventual bubble ending will be caused by higher interest rates on
a global basis. In other words, I will expect to see positive real interest
rates in most countries in contrast to today's environment of mainly negative
real interest rates.
Meanwhile,
if gold is to retain its strong seasonal consistency, particularly as seen in
odd numbered years, it will need to appreciate against all currencies, including
the strong Swiss franc, Singapore
$, Australian $ and New
Zealand $.